Art & Cultural Heritage
Overview
Our firm’s Art & Cultural Heritage practice focuses on plaintiff-oriented litigation and dispute resolution, involving a variety of cases dealing with looted art claims on behalf of individual holocaust victims, Jewish communities, American-Indian tribes or foundations and cultural institutions.
Whether dealing with Nazi-looted cases or more recent stolen artifacts cases, we have successfully represented a range of clients in complex litigation settings involving multiple jurisdictions, legal rules and tribunals. We have also successfully navigated to unique challenges involving such cases, such as the imbrication of multiple legal regimes, careful management of client expectations and sensitivities to cultural differences, and the importance of research efforts and interacting with historians and outside experts.
Recent Matters
We have successfully obtained the restitution of a Pissarro painting on behalf of a French Jewish family from a museum owned by a state university in Oklahoma. The painting is currently on display at the Orsay museum in Paris, France.
We have successfully obtained the restitution of a religious artifact on behalf of a Jewish community in Eastern Europe from a U.S. collector who attempted to sell it through a major New York auction house.
As counsel for several Arizona and New Mexico American-Indian tribes, we have been able to obtain the restitution of several religious artifacts from US-based private collectors and auction houses. We also advocated on behalf of those tribes before French jurisdictions to stop auction houses from auctioning similar religious artifacts.
Over the past 9 years, we have represented the Holocaust Art Restitution Project, a not-for-profit group based in Washington, DC, dedicated to the identification and restitution of artworks looted during armed conflicts. Our representation included corporate services, assistance with expert witness testimonies during litigation, interactions with several federal agencies in criminal investigations, as well as lobbying activities related to certain legislations.
We are currently representing the heirs of a major “Ecole de Paris” artist whose personal collection of sculptures was looted in Paris during the Nazi occupation.
Speaking Engagements
- Panel: Recent Developments in Cultural Heritage Restitution Cases: Where Are We and Where Are We going?, The Lawyers' Committee for Cultural Heritage Preservation Seventh Annual Conference, Mar 25, 2016
- US Tribal Art Claims versus the French Auction Houses & French Courts: The Hopi Case, New York University School of Professional Studies' Conference Art Crime and Cultural Heritage: Fakes, Forgeries, and Looted and Stolen Art, Jun 5, 2015
- Due Diligence In Cultural Heritage Litigation: Is There a Minimum Legal Threshold?, Oct 11, 2013
Media Appearances
- Nazi-Looted Painting Returns to Paris Almost 80 Years After Theft, Newsweek, Apr 26, 2017
- Did Russia meddle in recent US art theft legislation, The Times of Israel, Dec 16, 2016
- Editorial: Is the U.S. State Department's provenance research on immunity from seizure applications from foreign museums adequate?, Art Crime, Dec 5, 2016
- How a Nazi-Looted Painting Made Its Way to University of Oklahoma, Newsweek, Oct 14, 2016
- Should there be immunity for stolen art? Info Call on Bill S.3155 - the Foreign Cultural Exchange Jurisdictional Immunity Clarification Act, Art Crime Blogger, Sept 19, 2016
- Bill to Shield International Art Loans Gains in Senate, New York Times, Sept 16, 2016
- Russia critics, museums square off over Senate artwork bill, Politico, Sept 15, 2016
- No Immunity for Stolen Art: Info Call on Bill S.3155, Victims of Communism, Sept 14, 2016
- Bill would help families recover artwork looted by Nazis, USA Today, Jun 6, 2016
- University returns French Impressionist painting stolen by Nazis, The Washington Post, Feb 24, 2016
- University of Oklahoma will return Nazi-stolen painting to French family, Fox News, Feb 24, 2016
- University of Oklahoma Will Return Camille Pissarro Painting to Holocaust Survivor, ArtNet, Feb 24, 2016
- University of Oklahoma agrees to return Nazi-stolen painting, Seattle Times, Feb 23, 2016
- The University of Oklahoma has agreed to return a painting to a French Holocaust survivor that the Nazis had stolen from her family, US News, Feb 23, 2016
- University of Oklahoma to return Nazi-stolen painting, New York Post, Feb 23, 2016
- Native American Artifacts Sold at Paris Auction Despite Opposition, The Wall Street Journal, Jun 1, 2015
- House Introduces Resolution Directing University Of Oklahoma To Return Controversial Painting, KGOU, May 11, 2015
- Hopi Tribe Fights to Stop Sale of Sacred Artifacts, artNet, Dec 11, 2014
- Opinion: It’s Time to Stop Profiting from the Killing Fields- The return of five sandstone warriors to Cambodia last month was well overdue, artNet, Nov 1, 2014
- Pierre Ciric, Opinion: Hopi and Navajo Masks Auction Precedent in France Is Dangerous, Artnet News, Jul 25, 2014
- Pierre Ciric, Why Ronald Lauder is Right About Nazi-Looted Art in Museums, Artnet News, Jul 16, 2014